• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Otterwize

What You Otter Know About Personal Finance

  • Saving
    • Saving 101
    • Liv’n, Mov’n & Nosh’n
    • Saving Apps
    • Budgeting & Net Worth
    • Checking & Savings
    • Money Markets & CDs
    • Savings Blotter
  • Credit & Debt
    • Credit 101
    • Give Yo’self Credit
    • Paying Off Debt
    • Mortgages
    • Personal Loans
    • Auto Loans
    • Credit & Debt Blotter
  • Investing
    • Investing 101
    • Retirement Accounts
    • Robo-advisors
    • Advisor Look-Up
    • Opportunity Cost: Invest The Difference
    • The New 99%
    • Investing Blotter
  • Adulting
    • Adulting 101
    • Managing Your Career
    • Housing
    • Buying or Leasing a Car
    • Insurance
    • Taxes
    • Simmering Savings
    • Adulting Blotter
  • The New Economy
    • New Economy 101
    • The Sharing Economy
    • Side Hustles
    • Starting a Startup
    • The New Economy Blotter
  • Otter Tools
    • Personal Finance in 9 Words
    • Roadmap to Financial Independence
    • 10 Personal Finance Rules of Thumb
    • Top Ten’ers
Show Search
Hide Search
You are here: Home / Saving / Switch from This to That and Invest the Difference

Switch from This to That and Invest the Difference

You can save a lot of money by making simple substitutions in your everyday routine. 

This post may contain affiliate links. Otterwize may get commissions for purchases made through links in this post (at no additional cost to you). See our Advertising Disclosure for more information. As an Amazon Associate, Otterwize earns from qualifying purchases.

Simple lifestyle changes like cooking more at home, skipping the take-out coffee and muffin on your way to work, or brown-bagging your lunch can make a big difference in your finances. The raw savings from making these choices is significant enough, but these small changes in your daily routine could potentially add up even more if you invest the savings year after year. A useful way to measure the impact of these types of simple choices is to look at the opportunity cost of choosing one course of action over another. 

Opportunity cost is the benefit given up by choosing one alternative over another. In these everyday examples, the opportunity cost of choosing the more expensive alternative is the difference between the return from the option passed up (the less expensive option) and the return from the option selected (the more expensive option). The return from the option selected is zero in these cases, because the money has already been spent on that more expensive option; there is no savings left to be invested. So the opportunity cost of choosing the more expensive option would just equal the potential return from the less expensive option that was not chosen. This return can be expressed as the amount that could potentially have been earned by investing the cost savings over time.

The table below shows how switching daily or weekly routines over the long term could potentially result in very large amounts if the savings are invested and compounded over time.

  • If a 25-year-old swaps bottled water for filtered tap water every day until s/he reaches 65—assuming s/he drinks 1 liter of water each day—and invests those daily savings over time for 40 years, s/he could potentially have more than $200,000 at age 65 if the investments return an average of 10% per year.
  • If the 25-year-old cooks two more dinners at home every week until s/he turns 65—as opposed to eating in a restaurant on those two nights every week—and invests those weekly savings over time for 40 years at 10%, s/he would have more than $500,000 by age 65.
    • If s/he usually eats in a restaurant seven days a week but switches to cooking at home and eating out only one night per week every week until age 65, the invested savings over time for 40 years at an average return of 10% per year would exceed $1.6 million! 

For this to work, of course, the 25-year-old would have to actually invest the savings, i.e., the difference between what s/he could have spent on the more expensive option and what s/he actually spent on the less expensive option.

(Invest-The-Difference amounts compounded monthly for 40 years)

The point of this table is not to suggest that anybody should give up certain conveniences or pleasures all the time every day or every week for 40 straight years. There will of course be many dinners out, glasses of wine, and luscious desserts (as there should be). This table is not meant to be taken as a frugal bugle call (say that three times fast) for how to spend decades of your life. The point of the table is just to show that considering the opportunity cost of individual spending decisions can drastically change the equation. 

Getting into the habit of choosing a less expensive item (if you could have otherwise “afforded” the more expensive item) can free up money that you could invest, resulting in the potential for generating significant value over the long term. In this way, the “real” cost of a particular item is not just the raw cost of that item. It can also include the opportunity cost of that item—what you might have had if you had used that same amount of money some other way.

We all have choices to make every day about how to spend our money. If our hypothetical 25-year-old reduces his/her alcohol tab by $10 every week (see table row 10)—so about 1-2 drinks with tip at many bars and restaurants in America—that would save $43.33 per month. If s/he takes the monthly savings and invests it in the market at 10% compounded earnings until his/her 65th birthday, s/he would have $274,022! Even if the savings are put into an FDIC-insured CD earning 2% per year, the total would still be $31,823 by age 65. If given the choice of having that extra 1-2 drinks per week over that entire time frame or not having that extra 1-2 drinks per week but ending up with a nest egg of more than a quarter of a million dollars by age 65, doesn’t having “just one more” seem a little bit more difficult?

Also, be sure to check out our “The $200,000 Cheeseburger” post (another Invest the Difference story).

Have you ever switched from this to that? Dive in to the Comment Stream below and share your thoughts!


Chart prices accurate as of fall of 2017. Prices may vary over time.

(1) Smoking vs. quitting smoking: see Watching Your Money Go Up In Smoke, first table, 50-state average = $187.37/month.

(2) Bottled water vs. filtered water:

  • Brita 10-cup water pitcher is $29 at Target, with $3 coupon from Brita = $26.30 
  • Replacement filters (last 40 gals each) on Amazon are 6 for $28.29: (assume $30 with average tax) (“For best performance, change Brita pitcher replacement filter every 40 gallons or 2 months” )
  • Assume 1 person drinks 1 liter/day (a little more than 4 cups/day)
  • 40 gals = 151.4 liters
  • 1 liter of water at Peapod = $1.09 + 7 cents tx = $1.16
  • Assume keep pitcher for 10 years (amortize cost of pitcher over 10 years)
  • Cost of 1 year of Brita-filtered water:
    • $30/10=$3
    • At 1 liter/day, need 2.4 replacement filters/year
    • 1 filter is $30/6=$5.00 $5.00 x 2.4 filters/yr=$11.60/year for filters
    • Total cost per year of filter each year for 10 years is $12 + $3 = $15/year for 10 years (assume cost of 1 liter of tap water/day is negligible)
  • Cost of 1 year of bottled water (1 liter per day x 365 days) = $1.16 x 365=$423.40
  • Net savings to use Brita filter = $423.40 – $15 = $408.40. Round down to $400/year saved for one liter per day per person = $34.03/month 

(3) Buy lunch vs. bring lunch to work:

These amounts are variable, based on price of restaurant, location, items ordered, etc. For the purposes of this table, we assumed cost of buying lunch with tax for 1 person = $8.00, and we assumed bringing lunch from home for 1 person costs $3.00. These estimates are rounded and may be higher or lower than anyone’s actual amounts. Estimated savings = $5 per person per work day. Assume 240 work days/year (this assumes vacation plus holidays plus sick days average 4 weeks off = 48 work weeks/year times 5 days/week = 240 work days. Total savings = $5/day times 240 work days = $1,200/year = $100/month

(4) Buy coffee vs. bring coffee to work:

  • Coffee: Starbucks 12 oz tall; $2.17 incl. tax (Chicago, IL price)
  • Assume $.08/cup with tax for sugar and milk at home ($2.50 per 4 lb. bag Domino sugar and $3.50/gal. milk)
  • Assume $0.51 to make 8 oz from Starbucks pound of coffee (includes cost of coffeemaker amortized, plus filters, and electricity)
  • 12 oz cost at home = $.77 + $.08= $.85 cents 
  • $2.17-$.85 cents=$1.32 saved to make at home/day
  • Assume 240 work days/year (this assumes vacation plus holidays plus sick days average 4 weeks off = 48 work weeks/year times 5 days/week = 240 work days
  • 240 x $1.32 saved/day=$316.80/yr = $26.40/month 

(5) Eat dinner in restaurant 1 night/week vs. cook dinner at home 1 night/week: 

These amounts are variable, based on price of restaurant, location, courses ordered, etc. For the purposes of this table, we assumed cost of restaurant dinner with tax and tip for 1 person = $15, and we assumed cooking at home for 1 person costs $5/serving. These estimates are rounded and may be higher or lower than anyone’s actual amounts. Estimated savings = $10 per person per dinner. At 52 weeks/year, that comes to $520/year, which is $43.33/month to eat in restaurant one night per week instead of cooking that one night per week.

(6) Eat dinner in restaurant 2 nights/week vs. cook dinner at home 2 nights/week: 

($43.33/month for once a week) times 2 = $86.66/month

(7) Eat dinner in restaurant 3 nights/week vs. cook dinner at home 3 nights/week: 

($43.33/month for once a week) times 3 = $129.99/month

(8) Eat dinner in restaurant 5 nights/week vs. cook dinner at home 5 nights/week: 

($43.33/month for once a week) times 5 = $216.65/month

(9) Eat dinner in restaurant 6 nights/week vs. cook dinner at home 6 nights/week: 

($43.33/month for once a week) times 6 = $259.98/month

(10) Reduce alcohol consumption by $10/week:

$10/week times 52 weeks = $520/year =$43.33/month

(11) Soft drink vs. tap water at restaurant:

  • Assume soft drink = $3 with tax and tip (estimate $2.50/drink plus tax and tip)
  • $3 x 52 weeks = $156/year
  • $156/12 mos. =$13/month

(12) No coupons vs. $4.00/week in coupons for necessities:

  • $4/week x 52 weeks = $208
  • $208/12 mos. = $17.33/month

 

Primary Sidebar

sa-captivate-placeholder

Ad Disclosure

Featured Posts

The Quarterly Cleanse: 8 Ways to Ditch Your Physical and Digital (& Some Psychological) Baggage
To Buy or Not to Buy: What Shakespeare Teaches Us About Shopping With Intention
10 Ways to Throw a Bachelor or Bachelorette Party on a Budget
How Saving $5.25 a Day Could Turn a 25-Year-Old Into a Millionaire
9 Red Flags that Layoffs or Closings May Be Imminent (and 10 Ways to Protect Yourself)

Recent Posts

  • From Pineapple to Paris: Divorce Mediation and Spending Priorities
  • 11 Restaurant Apps to Save You Money
  • Save Money at the Grocery Store by Giving Up These 12 Everyday Items
  • 18 Ways to Summer on a Budget: Don’t Let Your Finances Get [Sun]burned
  • Unbridled Spending: 12 Wedding Gift Ideas on a Budget

Ottergram

otterwize

Eric & Janet
Millennial & Boomer
Finance guy & lawyer
2 generations-2 points of view
What u otter know about #personalfinance #financialindependence

Instagram post 2196823116705845312_6039557123 An interesting equilibrium. #officerules #worklifebalance #equilibrium #allinadayswork #georgecarlin #georgecarlinquotes #9to5 #9to5life #cubiclelife
Instagram post 2195144169412876279_6039557123 Don’t take on debt to buy holiday gifts. (That would just be a gift for your credit-card company.) Come up with a reasonable holiday budget and stick to it. #holidayshopping #holidaybudget #diyholidaygifts #buyless #frugalholidays #debtfree #debtfreecommunity #dfc #debtfreeholidays #debtfreeliving #debtfreejourney #debtfreegoals #holidaybudgeting #personalfinance
Instagram post 2191482000678683769_6039557123 After mortgage debt, student loan debt is the second highest form of debt, currently at $1.50 trillion in Q3 2019. You can see from the age charts that the 70+ year-olds have a slightly higher debt balance than the 18-29 year-olds, although most of the over-70 debt is mortgage debt, and most of the 18-29 debt is student loan debt. Charts are from the Federal Reserve Board of New York, Center for Microeconomic Data Quarterly Report on Household Debt and Credit 2019: Q3 (released Nov. 2019) https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/interactives/householdcredit/data/pdf/HHDC_2019Q3.pdf #studentdebt #mortgagedebt #creditcarddebt #cardebt #payoffdebt #debtfreecommunity #debtstatistics #debtstats #debtfreecommunity #dfc #debtfreegoals #studentloandebt #demographics #personalfinance
Instagram post 2190815073652265074_6039557123 Giving Tuesday isn’t just about donating money. You can also give your time, skills, voice, goods, or even social media support to charitable organizations. #givingtuesday #unselfie #contribution #giveback #givingback #generosity #greatgiving #donate #nonprofit
Instagram post 2190063359550561877_6039557123 Buying a $100 item for 50% off won’t save you $50, it will cost you $50. Good deals on Cyber Monday are only good if you needed to buy that item anyway. #cybermonday #cybermondaysale #onsale #discounts #holidayshopping #savingmoney #spendless #savemoney #nospendchallenge #lessismore #frugality #buyless #shopwithintention #budgeting #holidaybudget #financialindependence #personalfinance
Instagram post 2188624471762325947_6039557123 Today is the 10th Annual Small Business Saturday. Support your local shops, artisans, and small businesses. #shopsmall #shopsmallsaturday #shopsmallbusiness #shoplocal #smallbusinesssaturday #smallbiz #familyownedbusiness #familyowned #localmerchants #supportlocalartisans #localartisans #handmade #handmadegifts #momnpopshop #momnpopbiz #smallbusiness #smallbizsat #mainstreetusa #supportlocalmerchants #shoplocalstores #personalfinance #supportyourlocalmerchants
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Footer

Otter Facts

About Us
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
Disclaimer & Advertising Disclosure
Contact Us

Subscribe

Connect

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
The information, data, and materials (“Information”) presented on the Otterwize website are for general informational and educational purposes only. The Information is not intended to be viewed as and does not constitute investment advice, financial advice, legal advice, tax advice, accounting advice, or any other professional advice. [Read More...]

© 2018–2019 Otterwize, Inc. All rights reserved.

  • Saving
    ▼
    • Saving 101
    • Liv’n, Mov’n & Nosh’n
    • Saving Apps
    • Budgeting & Net Worth
    • Checking & Savings
    • Money Markets & CDs
    • Savings Blotter
  • Credit & Debt
    ▼
    • Credit 101
    • Give Yo’self Credit
    • Paying Off Debt
    • Mortgages
    • Personal Loans
    • Auto Loans
    • Credit & Debt Blotter
  • Investing
    ▼
    • Investing 101
    • Retirement Accounts
    • Robo-advisors
    • Advisor Look-Up
    • Opportunity Cost: Invest The Difference
    • The New 99%
    • Investing Blotter
  • Adulting
    ▼
    • Adulting 101
    • Managing Your Career
    • Housing
    • Buying or Leasing a Car
    • Insurance
    • Taxes
    • Simmering Savings
    • Adulting Blotter
  • The New Economy
    ▼
    • New Economy 101
    • The Sharing Economy
    • Side Hustles
    • Starting a Startup
    • The New Economy Blotter
  • Otter Tools
    ▼
    • Personal Finance in 9 Words
    • Roadmap to Financial Independence
    • 10 Personal Finance Rules of Thumb
    • Top Ten’ers